Sunday vs Scotts: Mailed Subscription or a Retail Program You Buy Yourself?
Updated November 7, 2026
Sunday mails you the products and the timing for one season price that starts at $110. Scotts sits on every big-box shelf as a 4-bag program, but you own the spreader, the calendar, and the call on which step goes down when.

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Disclosure.
Sunday and Scotts are the same job packaged two completely different ways: Sunday decides what your lawn needs and mails it to you on a schedule, while Scotts sells you the products and leaves the plan, the timing, and the spreader work to you. Sunday builds its plan from your lawn size and a soil test kit that comes in the first box. Plans come in liquid, which you spray from the hose (lawns of 200 to 13,499 sq ft), or granular (3,000 to 32,999 sq ft). Sunday says a plan starts at $110 for the full season, and the total depends on your lawn size and plan type.
Scotts is the opposite trade. You buy granular bags off a shelf, you own a spreader, and you decide when each step goes down. There is no recurring charge and no lock-in, and the products are widely available and easy to replace, but nothing arrives to remind you and the program does not know anything about your soil. Scotts sells its program as a 4-bag bundle in small and large sizes, and store prices and rebates move through the season, so price the bundle for your square footage on the day you buy. The real question is whether you want a decision made for you or a shelf you control.
Where these figures come from: the Sunday price and plan sizes are from Sunday's plan cost help page (its homepage also advertises plans "as low as $55" and the free soil test in the first box), and the Scotts program contents from its 4-bag bundle page, and the Sunday weed killer ingredients from its weed control page, all read on 7 November 2026. We quote no Scotts dollar figure, because store prices and rebates change week to week.
Quick verdict
Sunday wins if you want the thinking, the timing, and the shipping handled for one season price. Scotts wins on availability and on buying only the steps you want, as long as you are willing to own the spreader, the calendar, and the decision about which step to put down when.
Sunday Lawn Care Subscription vs Scotts four-step retail program: at a glance
Model
Cost per season
Who applies it
Product form
What it covers
Weed killer ingredients
Soil test
Personalization
Grass identification
Scheduling and reminders
Availability
Product control
Lock-in and cancellation
Effort required
Best for
Verdict
APick Sunday if...
- You want the plan, the products, and the timing decided for you and shipped automatically.
- You want to avoid the 2,4-D and dicamba in a classic weed and feed bag.
- You want a soil test included without sourcing one yourself.
- You will genuinely skip applications if nothing shows up to prompt you.
- Feeding the lawn is the goal, not diagnosing weeds, disease, or pests.
BPick the Scotts program if...
- You want to buy one step at a time and shop rebates and store brands.
- You already own a spreader and do not mind calibrating it.
- You want to buy a single step this month and skip the next one without cancelling anything.
- You like being able to walk into a store today and have the product in hand this afternoon.
- You are happy to run your own calendar, or to use a free reminder tool for it.
Where to buy

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Disclosure.
Prefer other options? Browse retail granular fertilizer program you buy and apply yourself in our catalog.
Get your seasonal lawn care calendar for your ZIP
Every task, from feeding to weed control to aeration, has a window that shifts by region. Add your ZIP and we will email your 12-month lawn calendar right away, starting with this month.
Seasonal reminders and tips. No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Frequently asked questions
Is Sunday better than Scotts?
They are built for different owners. Sunday is better if you want the decisions removed: it builds a plan from your lawn size and a soil test, ships what you need when you need it, and its weed killers use iron HEDTA or soap rather than 2,4-D. Scotts is better if you want to buy off the shelf and run the program yourself, one bag at a time. Neither one identifies your grass, diagnoses disease, or tells you when to treat weeds, which is the gap the free tools here fill.
How much does Scotts lawn care cost per year?
It depends on your lawn size and how many steps you buy. Scotts sells the program as a 4-bag bundle in small and large sizes, and store prices and rebates change through the season, so price the bundle for your lawn on the day. The useful way to compare is per 1,000 square feet per application, because a bag is only cheap if it covers your lawn.
How does Sunday's price per square foot compare to Scotts?
Sunday does not publish a price per square foot. It quotes a season price for your lawn, starting at $110, and the total rises with lawn size and plan type. A Scotts Turf Builder Lawn Food bag is sold by coverage, such as 5,000 square feet per bag for one feeding. To compare fairly, get Sunday's quote for your lawn, then price four feedings' worth of Scotts bags (or the 4-bag bundle) for the same square footage. Count the spreader too if you do not own one.
Is Sunday weed control safer than Scotts weed and feed?
The ingredients differ, and the label decides safety for both. Sunday's selective weed killer, Dandelion Doom, uses iron HEDTA, and Sunday calls it an EPA biopesticide that is not organic. Its Weed Warrior uses ammonium soap of fatty acids, is OMRI-listed for organic use, and kills any plant it touches. The weed and feed bag in the Scotts program lists 2,4-D and dicamba, which are conventional synthetic herbicides. Whichever you use, follow the label's rate and keep kids and pets off for as long as the label says.
Can I cancel a Sunday subscription?
Yes, it is a subscription and you can cancel it, though as with any auto-ship service you want to do it ahead of the next shipment rather than after it lands. That is the structural difference from a retail program: with Scotts you simply stop buying bags and nothing happens, while with Sunday you have to actively end the arrangement. If you are unsure you will stick with a subscription, that difference is worth weighing before the first box ships.
Is Sunday fertilizer as effective as Scotts?
Grass reads nitrogen, not the brand. Both feed the lawn; they differ in form and in who picks the timing. Sunday mails a liquid you spray from the hose or a granular you spread, on dates it sets for your area. Scotts sells granular bags you put down on a calendar you run. For a typical home lawn either approach gives a good stand of grass if the timing is right. Timing and consistency matter more than the logo, which is why the reminder side of the problem is worth solving whichever you pick.
Do I need a spreader for Scotts products?
Yes, for the granular ones, and using one properly matters more than most people expect. A broadcast spreader set to the wrong rate is how lawns get striped, burned, or underfed. Every Scotts bag prints settings for common spreader models, so match the setting on your machine to the bag rather than guessing, and walk at a steady pace. A Sunday liquid plan avoids this by having you spray from the hose, which is a real convenience if you do not own a spreader. Sunday's granular plans still need one.
Which is better for a small lawn?
For a genuinely small lawn, retail bags usually win on cost, because one bag covers a small lawn for more than one feeding, while a Sunday plan has a starting price however small the yard. Sunday liquid plans start at 200 square feet, so it does serve tiny lawns, and it still wins on convenience and the included soil test. If the small lawn is also the reason you do not own a spreader, spraying from the hose may be worth the premium on its own.